Debate rages over whether Ethereum can be considered a security post-Merge


Xeggex

Less than 24 hours after Ethereum (ETH) completed its transition to proof-of-stake, the cryptocurrency community is enmeshed in arguments about whether the asset can now be considered a security or not.

SEC chairman statement

The Wall Street Journal reported that US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) chairman Gary Gensler said cryptocurrencycurrencies that allow staking could qualify as securities under the Howey test.

Gensler made this statement after a congressional hearing where he reiterated his belief that most cryptocurrency assets are securities. He said:

“From the crypto-coin’s perspective…that’s another indicia that under the Howey test, the investing public is anticipating profits based on the efforts of others.”

Gensler continued that intermediaries like cryptocurrency exchanges offering staking services offer services similar to lending even if there are changes in the labeling.

Gensler did not specify a cryptocurrency asset.

Community debates if Ethereum is security

Some within the cryptocurrency community argued that Gensler’s statement meant that Ethereum could now be classified as a security.

With Ethereum’s migration to PoS, the asset joins several other smart contract-enabled blockchains that use staking mechanisms to secure their network.

A strategy advisor at VanECK, Gabor Gurbacs, wrote that Ethereum’s migration from PoW to PoS “can draw regulatory attention.” Gurbacs said:

“To be clear, I am not saying that ETH is necessarily a security because of its proof model, but regulators do talk about staking in the context of dividends which if one feature of what securities laws call a “common enterprise”. There are other factors in the Howey test too.”

Adam Cochran argued that the commission’s chairman statement is a “baseless FUD from entities that don’t understand the tech, or gloss over legal elements.”

Crypto advocacy organization Coin Center in a Sept. 15 blog post, argued that Ethereum’s transition to PoS should not affect its classification.

The non-profit said the technological differences between PoW and PoS do not call for different treatments, saying “the economic realities of validating a chain through mining and validating a chain through staking are similar.”

Meanwhile, Bitcrypto-coin (BTC) maximalists, including Michael Saylor, only tweeted the Wall Street Journal report. Saylor had previously declared ETH security.

An investment Manager Timothy Peterson said;

“(An) average person probably doesn’t understand why, but Ethereum is now an unregistered security.”





Source link

Latest

U.S. Regulators Are Coming for Crypto. How Will the Future Look?

Key Takeaways Several recently proposed bills and ongoing enforcement...

How Much Energy Do NFTs Use? Less Than You May Think

Key Takeaways NFTs have faced major criticism concerning their...

Newsletter

spot_img

Don't miss

U.S. Regulators Are Coming for Crypto. How Will the Future Look?

Key Takeaways Several recently proposed bills and ongoing enforcement...

How Much Energy Do NFTs Use? Less Than You May Think

Key Takeaways NFTs have faced major criticism concerning their...
spot_imgspot_img

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

ajax-loader
Send this to a friend